Forum

 
You must be logged in to post Login


Lost Your Password?

Search Forums:


 






Wildcard Usage:
*    matches any number of characters
%    matches exactly one character

[Symphony of Doom] layout critique

Post
Member

walkerp

Montréal

posts 5

4:04 pm December 1, 2009

Hello Joshua and all,

I hope the studio is open.  I have finished the first pass of the layout for my Spirit of the Century "module" and would greatly appreciate some feedback.

My motivation for doing this is threefold: to properly archive adventures I have created and run and to share them with others and to learn some design.  I run a lot of one shots and a great deal of prep goes into them.  If they are good enough, I'l take feedback from the players and rework it and run it again.  However, I have a collection of adventures that are a bunch of sheets, notes, characters and so on all collected in a folder and I find it disatisfying.  It doesn't feel complete.  So I figured I could design them into a single, easily distributable package, then I could keep them in a neat, archivable and easily accessible format for myself and possibly for others.

I chose to go with 7" x 8.5" size because it makes a small booklet and can be printed out by anyone with access to a printer that does 8.5" x 14".  If you can do it double-sided, then you can print out the spreads and have yourself a proper book.

Currently, the image on the front cover is just a stand-in.  I have an illustrator friend who is drawing the climactic scene for the cover.  The info on the inside front cover is also not complete.  The rest of the text is complete.  I'm looking specifically for critique on the layout design, but if anything jumps out at you in the text or the overall adventure, I am open to hearing about it.

You can find the pdf here.

My real name is Conan but I'd really prefer it not be used online for reasons nothing other than identity security.

Guest

joshua

5:42 pm December 1, 2009

Post edited 1:31 am – December 2, 2009 by joshua


The door is, indeed open! I've been running around too much to actually let anyone know.

Off the top of my head, though:

  1. 14:17 is a very curious shape. Why that, instead of the 17:10 of the half-letter?
  2. I think the indentation of the paragraphs in your colophon is making the left margin of your text mushy because it's out in the center. Does unindented text work?
  3. Long URLs are pretty impractical. Are you just saying where you got them? If so, I think it's probably fine. But if you expect people to go there, you might want to TinyURL them.
  4. Your use of small caps serifs in titles and all-caps sans is working nicely for me.
  5. Is Neff Rastopopolous named after Roberto Rastapololous from Tintin?
  6. The boxes on page 3 feel cramped to me. Do you need the boxes? Can you achieve that separation with space instead of heavy lines?
  7. Similarly, the leading on the section headers — “ROBBERY!” and the like — feel cramped to the line below.
  8. If this is to be printed as a booklet, you'll have to impress it for bookletness. Check out the “Print Booklet” capabilities in the File menu. I don't know if it will allow you to print to PDF from there. I haven't messed with that stuff for a while.
  9. How did you decide on the margins and gutter?
  10. Have you tried setting this without hyphens?
  11. Why is there an ornament at the end of page 9, but not any other section?

The Century Club is an actual club in New York. Is that part of the Spirit of the Century setting?

Member

walkerp

Montréal

posts 5

7:48 pm December 1, 2009

I guess I should respond here point by point?

  1. Paper size, simply because we have way too much 8.5 x 14 paper in the office where I work, so it's okay to use some of it for personal reasons.  I played around with it and tabloid and found tabloid way too big and this size seemed to work with the content I had.  I find it looks okay printed out, a nice size to hold and flip through.
  2. The colophon at this point is not done.  I stuck the url's in there simply to not forget them.  I guess I should really put it together.  It's just that I wasn't sure about the content.  Is there a boilerplate or some kind of standard for colophons?  Point taken about the indent; I probably won't put one in.
  3. Thanks on the use of caps!  They aren't "true" small caps in the titles, though that could be an option in the typeface.  I need to look into that.
  4. Nice call on Rastopopolous!  You got it. :)
  5. I don't think I do need the boxes, but I wasn't sure how to make the data stand out a bit from the text.  I'll try with just space or perhaps only horizontal lines.  I think you are right about the cramping.
  6. I'll try it with a bit more space.  I really didn't do much with leading.  Learning about that and spacing (kerning?) is my next step.
  7. I have succeeded in outputting it in booklet form.  Would it be helpful if I put a pdf of that up so people can print it out themselves?  The spread in the middle looks quite cool across a single page, I found.
  8. Margins and gutter: I didn't Surprised  I just went with the defaults.  It all seems so subtle and I have no knowledge or guidelines.  
  9. No, I haven't gone without hyphens.  I think that would then require a bit of manual kerning to make it all fit nicely, no?
  10. For the ornament, I just was looking for some ways to add some art to the document as it seemed a bit dry and text-heavy.  I was going to do it at the end of each section, but the text filled up a lot of that space, so I think I might just take it out now.
If you look at it printed out, each "Movement" is on the left hand side of the page and continues to the right, so you can read the whole thing with the booklet open.  In the "Intermezzo", which is also a scene of transition and travel for the PCs, I tried to give the reader a graphical sense of that change as well as of the non-linear structure of that scene.  How do you find that?
Thanks a lot for the feedback.  I'm going to play with those boxes.

My real name is Conan but I'd really prefer it not be used online for reasons nothing other than identity security.


About the xenoglyph Forum

Forum Timezone: America/New_York

Most Users Ever Online: 30

Currently Online:
1 Guest

Currently Browsing this Topic:
1 Guest

Forum Stats:

Groups: 1
Forums: 5
Topics: 83
Posts: 632

Membership:

There are 178 Members
There have been 13 Guests

There is 1 Admin

Top Posters:

Simon C – 90
lumpley – 40
Dan Maruschak – 30
doc – 15
DanielW – 12
MrSitouh – 8

Recent New Members: Hannah, ottto, Remko, Vandor, Mauro

Administrators: Robert Bohl (61 Posts)